Complaints & Appeals Policy
Education, Innovation and Social Futures (EISF) is committed to fair, transparent, and accountable editorial and publishing processes. Authors, reviewers, readers, and other stakeholders may raise legitimate concerns regarding editorial procedures, publication decisions, journal policies, or the conduct of the publication process.
Editorial Appeals
Authors may appeal an editorial decision when they believe that a significant error, misunderstanding, or procedural issue affected the assessment of their manuscript.
An appeal should clearly identify the manuscript, explain the specific grounds for the appeal, and provide a reasoned response to the editorial decision and relevant reviewer comments.
Grounds for Appeal
An appeal should be based on substantive concerns rather than disagreement with an editorial decision alone. Appropriate grounds may include:
- a significant factual or methodological misunderstanding;
- evidence that relevant information was overlooked;
- a material procedural irregularity;
- concerns regarding an undisclosed conflict of interest; or
- other circumstances that may have materially affected the fairness of the decision.
Appeal Assessment
Appeals will be considered by an appropriate editor who will review the original submission, peer-review reports, editorial correspondence, and the grounds provided by the author.
Where appropriate, the appeal may be referred to another editor or independent expert who was not substantially involved in the original decision.
Submission of an appeal does not guarantee that the original decision will be changed.
Complaints
Complaints may concern matters such as:
- editorial procedures;
- unreasonable delays;
- peer-review conduct;
- conflicts of interest;
- publication ethics;
- authorship or contributor concerns;
- corrections or post-publication matters;
- inappropriate editorial behaviour; or
- other aspects of the journal's publishing process.
Complaints should provide sufficient information to allow the journal to understand and assess the concern.
Handling of Complaints
EISF will seek to address complaints objectively, respectfully, and within a reasonable timeframe. Relevant records and information may be reviewed, and clarification may be requested from the individuals involved.
Complaints will be handled with appropriate confidentiality while recognising that some matters may require consultation with editors, reviewers, authors, institutions, ethics committees, the publisher, or other relevant parties.
Complaints Concerning an Editor
Where a complaint concerns the conduct or decision-making of an editor, the matter should be considered by another appropriate senior editor or publisher representative who is not directly involved in the issue.
Complaints Concerning the Editor-in-Chief
Where a complaint concerns the Editor-in-Chief, it will be referred to an appropriate representative of Scientific Scholarly Publishing or another independent person designated to consider the matter.
Research and Publication Misconduct
Complaints involving suspected plagiarism, fabrication, falsification, unethical research, authorship misconduct, undisclosed conflicts of interest, or other potential breaches of research integrity may be investigated under the journal's relevant ethics and integrity policies.
Where appropriate, the journal may contact an author's institution, ethics committee, funding organisation, or another relevant body.
Good-Faith Complaints
EISF welcomes legitimate concerns raised in good faith. Individuals raising concerns should provide accurate information and avoid knowingly false, misleading, abusive, or malicious allegations.
Outcome
Where a complaint or appeal identifies a substantive problem, EISF will take appropriate corrective action. This may include reconsideration of an editorial decision, correction of information, changes to editorial procedures, further investigation, or post-publication action where necessary.
The outcome will be communicated to the complainant to the extent appropriate, subject to confidentiality, privacy, and legal considerations.
Final Editorial Consideration
Following appropriate review of an appeal, the journal's resulting editorial decision will normally be considered final. Repeated appeals concerning the same matter will generally not be reconsidered unless significant new evidence becomes available.